Pro13 - it appears your new card is working properly. I think you need to study and learn how the aircrack-ng suite of tools work. I recommend you google aircrack-ng and read the material there.
Once you get a sense of how the aircrack-ng suite works, you might want to try this aircrack-ng tutorial on capturing WPA handshakes and cracking. The tutorial walks you through, step-by-step the exact commands you need to enter on your system and in your specific wireless environment. Jot down the commands and then practice them without running the tutorial script.
Study, try to answer your own questions, experiment and have fun.